Facebook Is Favoring Posts From Friends and Subscribers Over Fan Pages


There are some interesting things happening with Facebook lately…of course what else is new? They are always changing things to the chagrin of their user base but that doesn’t really stop them !

There appears to be a clear sense of favoritism being given to our friend activity and the subscriber option, which was made available in the new timeline that was launched in late September 2011. This preference is taking precedence over our fan pages posts in the news feeds.

What does this mean to your business?

It is getting more and more difficult to get our fan page content to show up in the news feeds of our fans and this seems to be the reason why.

I have been testing this over the past week. I have been actively trying to increase my subscriber base and my results have indicated that my personal profile posts are getting much more engagement than my fan page.

If you think about this for a minute, it makes total sense. People want to connect with real people and not necessarily a business or a logo. The fact that Facebook is giving preference to personal profiles over fan pages speaks to people’s need for authenticity in today’s marketplace.

I have always tried to keep my personal profile and my business separate but in an effort to test this principle myself, I posted a few business related posts to both my personal profile and to my fan page and the engagement on my personal profile was substantially higher. 

I took a look at Pete Cashmore’s personal profile versus his business profile, Mashable. Mashable has over 760,000 fans on Facebook. Pete’s personal profile has 239,000 subscribers which is less than one third of the connections yet he gets DOUBLE the engagement on his personal profile than he does on his fan page.

It is going to be important to start building your subscribers on your personal profile, sharing relevant and valuable content in order to gain more visibility on Facebook.

You can start optimizing your personal profile by setting up the new timeline if you haven’t already. Here are the instructions on how to get this set up quickly and easily.

Set up your timeline to tell your story. Stories sell and better yet, they trigger engagement!

 A few things that you need to focus on initially.


Choose a cover photo that represents who you are and what you are about. There are four display boxes that are visible to all when they first land on your wall. I would set them up to display your friends, photos, map and subscribers. You can change these at any time by clicking on the dropdown menu where you can choose other choices but these four are a great overview of who you are.

Facebook Subscribe Button

The Facebook subscribe button is similar to the Twitter follow button or the Google+ circle button. It is very new but something you should immediately put on your website. You can set yours up by visiting this site. It looks like this…










I have had mine on my website for just a few days and have noticed an increase in my subscribers.

TIP #1: Make sure that you have your “show pictures” turned on, as this will increase your subscribers. Again, remember, people are very visual and are drawn to graphics!

TIP #2: If you have met your 5000 friend limit on Facebook, when someone requests a friend connection, they automatically become a subscriber.

Subscriber Suggestions

This used to be friend suggestions and with the new timeline implementation it has changed to subscriber suggestions. This has huge marketing potential! The old friend suggestion feature limited us to people that were connected to us through our friend connections. The new subscriber suggestion allows you to be suggested to anyone! This could potentially expose your profile to thousands of new subscribers in a very short period of time.

  • Understand your privacy settings on your personal profile and figure out what content is for friends only and what is “public” content.
  • Secondly, decide what 'public' content you want to share on your personal profile versus your fan page. For example; you could share your blog content on your personal profile as a public post.
  • Post content on your fan page as the page administrator and comment on your page from your personal profile. This way, your fan page content gets into the news feed!
  • Now that people can subscribe, you can be more selective on who you wish to "friend".

This is free advertising for you and your brand if you handle correctly (you are not supposed to directly advertise on your personal profile but you can certainly share content) and it has more capability to engage more people than your fan page. Sad but true!

This is kind of tough thing to accept since so many of us have put so much time and effort into our fan page but if Facebook continues to give precedence to subscribers, we will be forced to flex.

The good news is that this is a brand new opportunity for all of us and the playing field is level. Most will start with very little subscribers and build steadily but with ultimately more engagement! 

Keep in mind that Facebook is constantly changing and this trend may not be the trend next week! However, I think that this is the direction Facebook is heading because, if you remember, Facebook was created to connect people not brands.



To receive Kim's "30 Fun and Creative Ways To Increase Your Facebook Likes", click here.









  1. says

    Thanks Kim! This is super helpful although I'm not a fan yet of the timeline. Going from side to side trying to read it makes me dizzy. I also feel like I must have my pics in order first before switching over. I'll definitely start posting as myself on my fan page.

  2. Carolynne says

    I'd be interested to hear your thoughts on the fact that Facebook actually discourages people from using their profile for business (or at least that is what I have been told). It is my understanding that Facebook wants to promote how useful it is for small businesses and are constantly encouraging pages to place ads, but they must realize it is money wasted for their clients if they make it so no one's page posts appear in fans' newsfeeds. I am wondering how they are going to reconcile this. You can't place an ad for a profile, can you?

    • adminadmin says

      I think it is a fine line…I would never advertise to sell something from my profile for example. I would also not place an ad that went to my personal profile. FB opening up the subscription button is just another opportunity to get YOU in front of more eyes.

  3. says

    Kim, It's good to hear that your experience with Facebook is similar to mine. I always seem to get more interaction and shares on posts to my personal page than my fan page. I always attributed it to the fact that I engage more on my personal page and that perhaps I was neglecting my fan page. After hearing that you've experienced the same thing, I think I'll stop worrying about my fan page and stick with what's been working for me all along. 
    Thanks for the great tips on creating my Timeline too. I really have to get that done.
    Look what Sherryl Perry just posted..What Impact does Social Media Have on Businesses?My Profile

  4. says

    This is great info Kim.  I have been thinking along the same lines and have been focusing on my personal page more for business lately.  I've also put off (procrastinated) setting up my timeline because it's something new, but with your insight I'm encouraged to head over there now.  Thanks!

  5. says

    Hi, Kim. Thank you for bringing this to my attention. I may be missing something here. I followed the directions. I have the codes generated. I thought I was supposed to just put that into my website. What am I missing? Thank you. Michelle

  6. Bonnie Chase says

    With the changes to facebook, does it still make sense to maintain a fanpage and a personal profile?  In the past the personal profile limits made it necessary to start a fan page.  Now with the subscribe feature you can grow your profile larger.  I am hearing people are getting less interaction on their fan pages than their personal profile.  Seems like facebook is discouraging business pages.
    Thanks for the great article.

    • adminadmin says

      Bonnie, the problem with Facebook is that it is constantly evolving. It was never designed for business but, as with all marketing channels, is simply an evolution of what is. I think Facebook tried to divide the two entities. What I see happening now is them trying to balance their platform with the features that are attracting people to Google+. I think this will level out and hoping that fan pages do not become extinct in the meantime. Those who have good engagement on their fan pages, still have good engagement but those that are just starting out, can struggle a bit because of FB’s new structure. Doesn’t mean it can’t be done…just means it is going to be a bit tougher.

  7. says

    Hey Kim, love your post and I have been wrestling over this for awhile. I have begun to build followers on my fan page and have really kept my personal page for family. I am an artist and when I began painting 12 years ago I started painting using my  middle name as a 'brush name' probably out of insecurity more than anything. I have a problem now though because my personal page is not under the same name. I have been wondering what to do about this for ages. What began as me just wanting anonymity is now a problem. Just wondering what you think?

  8. Mary says

    Thanks Kim, I've noticed my page engagement drop and then peak when my friends comment. I'm also noticing an increase in sponsored posts appearing in my feed. The time we spend building our tribe and engaging with great content and sharing resources is requiring more hoop jumping. 

    • adminadmin says

      I don’t look at it like hoop jumping. I look at it as a constant, connected approach to serving your audience. We can’t control what FB does but we can control what we do 😉

  9. says

    Hi Kim, I truly agree with everything you said. My team and I noticed the same thing .. we have around 6,000 members on our page but I keep asking my team members that I feel Facebook doesn't show all the posts from our page to the members and maybe selects the people it chooses to show the posts to because how can you tell me out of 6,000 members only 30 or 50 are active. That was why I think they created the sponsor posts option or promote posts option so they can make money off businesses who want to operate on there platform. It's just a theory but I think it's right. I am now thinking of sponsoring posts to test this theory and see if it opens our posts to more people. What do you think?

  10. says

    I have noticed the same thing between my public pages and my personal profile. Here's the problem I have with that, privacy. I like to have my privacy on my personal profile. I haven't figured out how I want to handle trying to have my profile public while maintaining privacy. Decisions decisions.

    • Kim Garst says

      100% absolutely yes. In fact, I would argue that is even more relevant. The bigger companies have much more resources available to them to get their message out besides social media. Social media is a level playing field and you Facebook Fan Page can be just as good or better than a Fortune 500 company’s page. Name anywhere else in the business marketing world where that is the case.
      Look what Kim Garst just posted..Focus: Your New Social Media Superpower!My Profile

  11. says

    I can back up your research, by a simple but unrecommended exercise…

    I realized that my Klout.com page wasn’t plugged into my company fan page on Facebook. So, I added it. What I didn’t realize is that when I hit enter, I switched my personal facebook to my company page.

    I rather freaked a lot when my Klout score dropped overnight from 63 to 55.

    When I asked Klout about it, they explained that my personal page has higher klout than the fan page. So, I switched it back.

    I think both klout and Facebook have it right, It is, after all, all about engagement. The customers don’t want to engage a bunch of bottles or even what’s in them, they want to engage me and my husband, @Peppermaster (who’s mostly too busy to engage much, but tries).

    It seems to work, because we’re getting more and more engagement everywhere and it’s all personal.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

CommentLuv badge